Apple replant: the old pit is still the old soil
Digging out the tree doesn’t dig out the fatigue.
- The old tree is gone; the same pit remains.
- The new tree stays weak, roots don’t explore.
- A newly planted tree can yellow from shortage, but an old hole is clearly worse.
- Still poor after watering — dig the root.
- Don’t plant the old pit with the old recipe; don’t leave old roots in the new root zone.
- Change the hole / the soil: Stagger it if you can. This is the most solid step
- Name what you see before you feed.
- If leaves, roots and the surface disagree, stop.
What you see in the field
The old tree is gone; the same pit remains. The new tree stays weak, roots don’t explore.Patchy dead plants: look at the roots first — knots, brown rot, stained pipes — not the thin white roots of hunger. A rotated neighbour that still looks well is the contrast that counts.
Tap to enlarge. The caption says what to photograph. Missing field photos are marked as to-be-added.
Why it looks like this
The field looks like this because the root cannot take water or nutrients the usual way. Fix the soil condition first — drainage, salt, acidity, compaction or a salt of fertiliser — then a thin feed. Rates live in the range on this page; confirm with a local station and the label.
Easy to mix up
Looks like “Short of fertiliser”
A newly planted tree can yellow from shortage, but an old hole is clearly worse.
Looks like “Dry weather”
Still poor after watering — dig the root.
Do this / don’t do that
- 1The old tree is gone; the same pit remains. The new tree stays weak, roots don’t explore.
- 2Move the station if you can. Fresh soil or substrate. Rotted organic matter in the root zone. Don’t reuse the old water-fertiliser recipe.
- 3Don’t plant the old pit with the old recipe. Use the range on this page only as a range. Confirm with a local station and the product label.
Don’t do this first
- Don’t plant the old pit with the old recipe; don’t leave old roots in the new root zone.
Rate range
Change the hole / the soil
Stagger it if you can
This is the most solid step.
Rootstock
A resistant rootstock, locally
Ask the fruit-tree station.
These are ranges. Confirm with your local extension station and the product label.
When you see The old tree is gone; the same pit remains. The new tree stays weak, test. Write the field and the date on the bag.
Lesson video
2026-03-13 · Li Zeyu · For learning. Serious damage: local agronomist or a soil test.
For learning only. Fertiliser and pesticide decisions need a local agronomist and a soil test.
Not sure? Photograph the field to identify the problem